Which Crypto Assets will Benefit from the CLARITY Act?

Author logo
Patrick Dike-Ndulue
• • Updated
Post image

 

The CLARITY Act is stuck, and it may not survive the year. On September 15, 2026, the Senate voted 49-50 against advancing the bill, 11 votes short of the 60 votes it needed. Then on November 3, Democrats won control of both the House and the Senate.

 

That changes the math. Republicans still run Congress until January 3, 2027, but if the bill doesn't pass before then, it dies. Any new attempt would start from scratch in a Democratic-led Congress, with different committee chairs and different priorities. So where does that leave the coins this bill was supposed to help? Below, we walk through what the CLARITY Act would do, why it failed, what regulators are doing in its absence, and which assets would still stand to gain if a version of it were ever enacted.

What is the CLARITY Act?

The Digital Asset Market Clarity Act (H.R. 3633) is a market structure bill. Its main job is to answer a question the US has dodged for years: which crypto assets are securities, which are commodities, and which regulator is responsible for each.

 

Right now, the SEC tends to treat most tokens as securities, while the CFTC sees many of them as commodities. The bill set out to:

  1. Draw a clear line between SEC jurisdiction (securities) and CFTC jurisdiction (commodities).
  2. Define terms like digital asset, digital commodity, blockchain, and decentralized governance system.
  3. Create registration paths for exchanges, brokers, and dealers, including new CFTC categories for spot crypto trading.
  4. Treat customer crypto as protected "customer property" if a platform goes bankrupt.
  5. Give crypto businesses a rulebook instead of regulation-by-lawsuit.

It's not a tax bill, and it doesn't cover stablecoin issuance. That's handled by the GENIUS Act, which is already law.

How did the CLARITY Act start?

The House passed H.R. 3633 on July 17, 2025, by a wide bipartisan margin of 294 to 134. In the Senate, the work was split between two committees. The Agriculture Committee handled CFTC powers over spot markets and advanced its version, the Digital Commodity Intermediaries Act, 12-11 in January 2026. The Banking Committee handled definitions, securities rules, and stablecoin rewards.

 

A Banking Committee markup planned for January 15, 2026, collapsed at the last minute. It took four more months to get the bill through committee.

The core framework

  • Digital asset securities (SEC). Tokens whose value depends on the work of a founding team or company are subject to SEC rules, with disclosure requirements similar to those of public companies. The bill calls these "ancillary assets."

     

  • Digital commodities (CFTC). The CFTC gets authority over spot markets for digital commodities. A network can "graduate" from security to commodity once it's truly decentralized.

     

  • DeFi. The bill was meant to protect developers and software providers who don't control user funds. The final September drafts narrowed this, adding registration and anti-money-laundering rules for anyone who controls a DeFi trading protocol that isn't actually decentralized.

Why does the CLARITY Act matter?

Without clear rules, crypto companies often find out they broke the law only when the SEC sues them. Institutions stay on the sidelines, and builders move to places like Dubai, Singapore, and Switzerland. Meanwhile, the EU has had a full framework since MiCA took effect in December 2024. Supporters saw CLARITY as the US answer to that.

What happened in the Senate in 2026

The bill advanced further in the Senate than any crypto market-structure bill before it, but stalled on a procedural vote.

Date (2026)What happened
Sept 17Seven Democratic senators, including Ruben Gallego and Kirsten Gillibrand, call the vote "a setback, but not the end." No new text or vote follows.
Sept 15Senate rejects cloture 49-50. Sen. Thom Tillis enters a motion to reconsider, which keeps the bill technically alive.
Sept 14Sponsors release a last-minute draft with ethics rules for officials and new Treasury powers over stablecoin rewards. It's never adopted.
September 10Sen. Cynthia Lummis releases updated text tightening DeFi rules.
August 8Cloture filed. Vote set for September 15.
July 22Senate Republicans release combined Banking and Agriculture text. Sen. Elizabeth Warren says the ethics language still falls short.
June 1Banking Committee formally reports the bill to the full Senate.
May 14Banking Committee advances the bill 15-9. Every Republican and two Democrats (Gallego and Angela Alsobrooks) vote yes.
May 1Tillis and Alsobrooks release a stablecoin yield compromise.

The September 15 vote

The vote wasn't on the bill itself. It was a cloture vote on whether the Senate could even start debating it, which needs 60 votes. It got 49.

 

All 49 yes votes came from Republicans. The 50 no votes included every Democrat who voted, both independents, and four Republicans: Susan Collins, Josh Hawley, Jerry Moran, and Thom Tillis. Tillis voted no for procedural reasons so he could file a motion to reconsider. Sen. Chris Coons didn't vote.

 

Banking Chairman Tim Scott blamed Senate Democrats. Warren, the committee's top Democrat, said a bipartisan crypto bill was possible, "but not this bill."

Why the CLARITY Act failed

In the end, the bill didn't fail over market structure. It failed over three fights that had been running since January.

1. Ethics and conflicts of interest

This was the biggest one. Democrats wanted enforceable rules stopping senior officials, including the president, from issuing or profiting from crypto. The concern was tied to the Trump family's crypto ventures, including a memecoin, NFTs, and World Liberty Financial. Warren called an ethics provision a "red line," and in August Gillibrand said she wouldn't back the bill without one.

 

The Banking Committee left ethics out in May, saying it was outside its jurisdiction. The September 14 draft finally added a ban on officials issuing or sponsoring digital assets, with blind trust rules. It came one day before the vote and was never adopted.

2. Stablecoin rewards

Banks and crypto platforms never fully settled the yield question. Stablecoin rewards of 3.5-5% look a lot better than most savings accounts, and banks worry about deposits leaving. The May compromise banned yield on idle balances but allowed rewards tied to activity, such as payments or staking. Banking groups said it still left a loophole. The September draft added backup Treasury powers to limit rewards if community bank deposits started to flee.

3. Tokenized securities and DeFi

Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong pulled his support in January (keep the existing link to his X post), arguing the bill would effectively ban tokenized stocks, hand too much power to the SEC, and expose DeFi users to government data access. By May, no major industry player was publicly opposing the bill. But the late-September changes to DeFi rules gave both sides new things to argue about.

 

Sen. Lummis, the bill's lead Republican negotiator, later said Democrats blocked consumer protections that were already in the text. Either way, the final draft was submitted less than a day before the vote, leaving little time to build support.

What happens next?

The short answer: probably nothing until 2027. Here's why.

The midterms flipped Congress

Democrats won both chambers on November 3, 2026. They take over when the new Congress starts on January 3, 2027. Warren, who led the opposition to the current bill, is widely expected to chair the Senate Banking Committee, though no assignments are official yet. House Financial Services would also move to a Democratic chair.

 

That gives Democrats little reason to rescue a Republican-written bill now when they can write their own next year.

The lame-duck window is narrow

Republicans still hold their majorities until January 3. Two paths are technically open:

  • Reconsideration. Tillis's motion lets the Senate hold another cloture vote without starting over. It would need 11 more yes votes, mostly from Democrats.
  • A must-pass bill. Supporters could try to attach market-structure language to a December government funding bill (current funding runs out on December 11) or to the annual defense bill.

As of mid-November, nobody has announced a plan for either. Congress is spending its remaining weeks on government funding and on Trump's SEC and CFTC nominees. Prediction markets reflect that. In early November, Polymarket priced the odds of H.R. 3633 becoming law in 2026 at about 3%.

January 3, 2027: the bill dies

If nothing passes, H.R. 3633 will expire at noon on January 3, with the current Congress. Every bill would have to be reintroduced and go through committee again.

 

The next version will likely look different. House Democrats have reportedly discussed expanding Rep. Maxine Waters's "Crypto Investor and Consumer Bill of Rights" into a broader bill that gives the SEC more power and the CFTC a smaller role. That's still at the talks stage, with no bill text. Expect ethics rules to be part of any Democratic draft.

Regulators are moving without Congress

With the bill stuck, the SEC and CFTC are using their existing powers to fill some of the gaps.

Date (2026)AgencyAction
October 13CFTCPublishes an advance notice on crypto asset transactions and markets. Comments due December 14. A binding rule isn't expected before late 2027.
October 1-6SECProposes crypto custody changes for advisers and funds. Comments due December 7.
September 17SECGrants five-year conditional relief for certain venues trading tokenized stocks.
September 17CFTCNo-action relief for "passive software providers" that let users send their own orders.
August 20CFTCChairman Michael Selig tells staff to explore crypto market rules under existing authority, including a new venue type for leveraged crypto trading.
August 18SECProposes "Regulation Crypto Assets": token fundraising exemptions of up to $20M (Tier 1) and $75M (Tier 2) per year, plus a $5M startup exemption and a safe harbor.

This helps, but it isn't the same as a law. Agencies can't create a full spot-market licensing system or guarantee customers will get their crypto back in a bankruptcy. And agency rules can be rolled back by the next administration or struck down in court.

 

The stablecoin side is more settled. The GENIUS Act is already law, and the OCC is writing the rules for stablecoin issuers.

Which cryptocurrencies would benefit from the CLARITY Act?

The bill never named winners, but the Senate drafts created two clear routes to commodity status. Since none of this is law, think of it as a guide to which assets are best placed for whatever version comes next.

The mature blockchain pathway

Under the drafts, a blockchain counts as "mature" when no person or group under common control runs it. The tests: it works as intended, no single entity holds more than 20% of the supply or voting power, and no founder or company can push upgrades on its own.

  • Bitcoin (BTC): Already treated as a commodity by the CFTC and fully decentralized. Its status doesn't depend on this bill.
  • Ethereum (ETH): Broad validator distribution since the Merge makes it the other obvious fit.

The ETF fast track

The Senate Banking text included a shortcut. Any token that was the main asset of an exchange-traded product listed on a national exchange on January 1, 2026, would skip the maturity test and be treated as a non-security from day one.

 

That covered XRP, SOL, LTC, HBAR, DOGE, and LINK. This was one of the most contested parts of the bill. Warren filed an amendment in May to remove it, specifically naming XRP and Solana. Now that the bill has stalled, there's no automatic status for any of these tokens. Their ETFs keep trading, but a Democratic rewrite may not include this shortcut at all.

Stablecoins

Stablecoins are the one area where the US already has a law. The GENIUS Act sets the rules for "permitted payment stablecoins," with or without CLARITY.

  • USDC (Circle): Fully reserved and audited, so it's well placed under GENIUS.
  • PYUSD (PayPal): Backed by a large regulated company and likely to qualify.
  • DAI (Sky, formerly MakerDAO): Its upside depended on CLARITY's DeFi and decentralization rules, so it loses the most from the bill stalling.
  • USDT (Tether): Still faces more questions about transparency and US compliance.

What stays unresolved is yield. Without CLARITY, the line between banned interest and allowed activity-based rewards is still up for debate.

DeFi protocols

Protocols like Uniswap, Aave, Curve, and Compound would have gained legal cover for developers and software providers who don't hold user funds. The bill also said staking rewards and similar end-user distributions aren't securities offerings.

 

The September drafts already narrowed these protections. With the bill stalled, DeFi's main relief for now comes from agency moves like the CFTC's no-action letter for passive software providers.

Three scenarios from here

  1. Long shot: a lame-duck rescue. Republicans and enough Democrats agree on a rewritten text, likely with strong ethics rules, and pass it through reconsideration or a December must-pass bill before January 3. Possible on paper, but nobody is publicly pushing for it.

     

  2. Most likely: a restart in 2027. The bill dies, and a Democratic-led Congress writes a new one. Expect a bigger role for the SEC, tighter consumer protections, ethics rules for officials, and possibly no ETF fast track. Kalshi traders put the odds of a market structure law by October 2027 at around 21% as of mid-November.

     

  3. Meanwhile: rules by agency. Whatever Congress does, the SEC and CFTC keep writing rules under their existing powers. This brings some clarity, but it can be undone by the next administration or a court.

Our conclusions

The CLARITY Act was supposed to settle the technical question of who regulates crypto. It ended up stuck on political ones:

  1. Banks vs. crypto platforms over stablecoin yield and deposits.
  2. SEC vs. CFTC over which assets they control.
  3. Privacy vs. oversight in DeFi.
  4. New players vs. incumbents in tokenized securities.
  5. Ethics, given the president's family's crypto business.

In May we said the window for crypto-friendly legislation was open now and could close for years if it missed the midterms. It missed. The next bill will be written by a different majority, and it will probably be stricter.

 

One thing doesn't change with any of this: who controls your keys. No matter which agency ends up regulating exchanges and tokens, coins in a self-custody wallet stay in your hands.

CLARITY Act FAQ: status, rules, and beneficiaries

  • No. The House passed it in July 2025, and the Senate Banking Committee advanced it 15-9 in May 2026. But on September 15, 2026, the Senate voted 49-50 against starting debate, falling 11 votes short of the 60 needed.

  • Not officially, but close. A motion to reconsider keeps it technically alive until the current Congress ends on January 3, 2027. If it doesn't pass by then, it expires, and lawmakers have to start over.

  • Democrats won both chambers on November 3, 2026, and took control in January. Sen. Elizabeth Warren is expected to chair the Banking Committee. Any new bill will likely give the SEC more authority and include ethics rules for officials.

  • Under the Senate Banking text, tokens that were the main asset of an exchange-traded product on January 1, 2026, were XRP, SOL, LTC, HBAR, DOGE, and LINK. Since the bill hasn't passed, none of them have that status, and a future bill may drop the provision.

  • Under the drafts, a blockchain no single person or group controls, where no entity holds more than 20% of supply or voting power, and no one can push upgrades alone. Bitcoin and Ethereum are the clearest examples.

  • Less than you might think. Stablecoin issuance is already covered by the GENIUS Act, which is law. The open question is yield: whether platforms can pay rewards on stablecoin balances.

  • Three unresolved fights: ethics rules for officials, stablecoin rewards, and late changes to DeFi and tokenized securities rules. Ethics was the biggest. Democrats wanted enforceable limits on officials profiting from crypto, and that language only appeared one day before the vote.

  • Section 309 excludes decentralized finance activities, and Section 109 protects non-controlling blockchain developers who don't hold user funds. Protocols like Uniswap, Aave, Curve, and Compound stand to benefit, and Section 203 clarifies that end-user distributions, including staking rewards, do not constitute the offer or sale of a security.

  • No. The bill focused on exchanges, brokers, token issuers, and DeFi developers. Holding your own coins in a self-custody wallet works the same whether it passes or not.

Author logo
Author Patrick Dike-Ndulue

Senior editor covering crypto, onchain equities, and technology.

Author logo
Reviewed by Tangem team

We are a team of Tangem Wallet users dedicated to simplifying self-custody for everyone.